AJ's Pizza Menu (Update 2026)

AJ's Pizza offers a straightforward yet diverse menu, perfect for satisfying any craving. The star of the show is their legendary 16-inch pizza, sliced into generous eight pieces. Featured options include classics like Cheese and Alfredo Sauce pizza, as well as hearty favorites like Supreme and Meat pizzas. For those leaning towards lighter fare, AJ's serves fresh-baked flatbread subs alongside crispy chips or a side salad, with enticing choices like Philly and Turkey Bacon Ranch Club.

For a quick snack or an appetizer, patrons can indulge in 1 lb. or 1/2 lb. wings. And do not overlook the calzones, combining delectable fillings wrapped in oven-baked dough.

For a complete meal, the Spring Mix Salads, like the Grilled Chicken and Spicy Chicken salad, appeal to the health-conscious without sacrificing flavor. The menu’s well-rounded nature caters to both adventurous eaters and those who prefer comfort foods, making each visit to AJ's a delightful experience.

Pizzas are one size only. 16 inches 8 slices
Fresh Baked Flat Bread Subs chips or salad included
Spring Mix Salads
Wings
Calzones
Sides
Ice Cream
Lunch Specials
AJ's Pizza Menu image 1
AJ's Pizza Menu image 2
AJ's Pizza Menu image 3
AJ's Pizza Menu image 4

Featured Dishes

Dough
Dough
Hot Wings
Hot Wings
Calzone
Calzone
Pizza with Ham Pepperoni Black Olive and Onion
Pizza with Ham Pepperoni Black Olive and Onion
Cheese Pizza Slice
Cheese Pizza Slice
Double Pepperoni Pizza
Double Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Parm Sandwich
Chicken Parm Sandwich
Pepperoni Cheesesticks
Pepperoni Cheesesticks
AJ's Pizza

AJ's Pizza Interior, Food, Ambiance

AJ's Pizza exudes a relaxed and friendly ambiance, making it the perfect spot for family gatherings or casual hangouts. The interior boasts a cozy setting filled with cheerful décor that reflects the local culture of Bayfield. Walls adorned with community photos offer a glimpse into the vibrant spirit of the area, encouraging a sense of unity and belonging.

When it comes to the food, the irresistible aroma wafting through the restaurant entices diners as they settle in. Whether enjoying a cheesy slice of pizza or sharing a platter of wings, the sound of lively conversations fills the air, enhancing the inviting atmosphere. This combination of ambiance and quality food creates an experience that keeps patrons returning.

AJ's Pizza

About AJ's Pizza Food and Specialties

At AJ's Pizza, the commitment to quality shines through. This locally owned pizza place prides itself on using fresh ingredients to create mouthwatering dishes that hit the spot. The pizzas here boast crispy crusts and generous toppings, especially the loaded Supreme pizza featuring a medley of veggies and meats. For true pizza lovers, the greasy goodness of their Meat pizza satisfies cravings, while veggie lovers find joy in the Veggie pizza brimming with freshness.

To complement the pizzas, AJ's offers Pigs in a Blanket and flavorful Gyros that have gained a loyal following. The calzones, stuffed to the brim, invite diners to experience a comforting twist on traditional pizza. Each dish presents incredible value for money, providing portions that leave customers feeling satisfied. AJ's blends beloved American classics with unique twists to create food that is truly special.

AJ's Pizza

AJ's Pizza showcases a commitment to quality and community that resonates through its menu. Specializing in pizza, the restaurant embraces hearty ingredients and traditional recipes that bring comfort to every meal. Each dish served reflects a dedication to affordability and generous portion sizes, ensuring patrons receive great value without sacrificing taste.

The vision of AJ's Pizza remains rooted in serving up delicious food that creates memorable experiences.

Attention to customer feedback helps evolve their menu, offering beloved classics alongside exciting new options that keep locals coming back. Their focus also includes providing a family-friendly environment where everyone feels welcome. The motto is simple; good food should be accessible and enjoyed together, fostering connections with each meal.