AJ's Pizza

Discover AJ's Pizza in Bayfield, CO, your local favorite for delicious, generously portioned pizzas, gyros, calzones, wings, and green chili. Enjoy great value, friendly service, and irresistible flavors at 381 E Colorado Dr #3. Call +1 970-884-0400 today!

Welcome to AJ's Pizza

Signature Dining Experience

AJ's Pizza
AJ's Pizza
AJ's Pizza
AJ's Pizza

AJ's Pizza stands as a cherished gem in the heart of Bayfield, Colorado. Just a stone's throw away from vibrant local life at 381 E Colorado Dr #3, this locally owned pizza restaurant draws in both residents and visitors alike. Known for its cozy atmosphere and warm service, AJ's Pizza focuses on hearty meals that appeal to a wide range of taste buds. The menu features a diverse selection that goes beyond just pizza, offering mouth-watering calzones, fresh salads, and signature wings.

Committed to quality and value, AJ's Pizza ensures every dining experience satisfies appetites and wallets alike. Whether it's a family gathering or a quick lunch after a hike, this spot invites everyone to taste the goodness of homemade food made from fresh ingredients.

Location & Contact

Address

381 E Colorado Dr #3, Bayfield, CO 81122, United States

Phone

+1 970-884-0400

Social Media

About

AJ's Pizza
AJ's Pizza
AJ's Pizza
AJ's Pizza

AJ's Pizza proudly represents the spirit of Bayfield, combining a welcoming atmosphere with a menu that reflects community flavors. This local establishment is a go-to spot for comforting and hearty meals. With over 39 distinct dishes on the menu, AJ's caters to various cravings without breaking the bank. Many customers rave about the delicious 'pigs in a blanket' and the generous portion sizes that make every visit worthwhile. From the creamy Alfredo Sauce Pizza to the classic Meat Pizza, AJ's ensures a fulfilling experience for pizza lovers of all kinds.

Each dish represents a labor of love and commitment to using fresh, quality ingredients that speak for themselves, often garnished with vibrant flavors of green chili and mushrooms.

The flatbread subs receive just as much attention, featuring crafted options like the Roast Beef Club, making lunch a real treat for office-goers and busy families alike. With affordable prices averaging around $13 per dish, AJ's continues to be a favorite in the community. Beyond the food, AJ's Pizza encourages a friendly gathering place where conversations flow and friendships are formed.

This lively atmosphere makes it perfect for a night out or a casual lunch date. Envelop yourself in the essence of Bayfield with every satisfying bite, knowing that every meal served up at AJ's comes with a side of community spirit.

The commitment to customer satisfaction shines through not only in the quality of food but the hospitality extended to guests. Regular patrons often leave glowing reviews, expressing appreciation for the attentive staff and quick service. AJ’s remains a steadfast presence in the community, carving a niche as a comfortable and reliable dining option.

From a casual after-school pizza with friends to family dinners on the weekends, every visit feels like home. So next time you crave deliciousness served with a side of warmth and community love, AJ's Pizza is right where you need to be.

Work Hours

  • SundayOpen
  • MondayOpen
  • TuesdayOpen
  • WednesdayOpen
  • ThursdayOpen
  • FridayOpen
  • SaturdayOpen

At AJ's Pizza, patrons can enjoy the comfort of large-sized pizzas, cut into eight generous slices. Each pizza measures a solid 16 inches, providing plenty of cheesy goodness topped with flavorful options. The house specialities such as the Supreme Pizza brim with an array of toppings, while the Meat Pizza satisfies heartier appetites. Not only does AJ's serve exceptional pizzas, but the array of fresh-baked flatbread subs offers delightful alternatives, including the savory Philly and Turkey Bacon Ranch Club. For those craving something lighter, try the Spring Mix Salads—freshly prepared with wholesome ingredients like grilled chicken and vibrant veggies.

The restaurant excels in providing value, with an overall average dish price of $13.03 across its extensive menu. Don't skip the sides either, boasting loaded curly fries or cheesy breadsticks to round out your meal. Additionally, AJ’s recognizes the importance of indulging your sweet tooth, offering delightful ice cream treats to top it all off.

AJ's Pizza

AJ's Pizza exhibits a charming façade that invites passersby to step inside and enjoy a meal. The exterior blends rustic charm with a bit of modern flair, featuring inviting signage and a casual setting that hints at the delightful dishes awaiting inside. Locally-themed decorations add a welcoming touch, making it easy to feel at home as soon as you arrive. The outdoor seating area provides a relaxed environment, ideal for enjoying a slice of pizza on a warm Bayfield day. The overall vibe bursts with friendly energy, perfect for gathering with family and friends while indulging in satisfying food.

Customer Reviews

Spicy chicken salad was amazing. The salad had fresh young greens, tomatoes, bacon, blue cheese, and hard boiled eggs. The surprise element was that the red onion was lightly grilled and slightly caramelized. That took the salad to the next level. Highly recommended.

R
Randi M.

The 5$ pizza slice is such a great deal and it's so big you get two pieces. The pigs in a blanket are only 3$. 6$ with a drink and chips. Never had a bad meal here. The cook was super friendly. I love that they don't rip you off. There's not a lot of seating but that's okay. Great chickens wings too. A big pizza can be expensive but they're really good. The chicken mushroom pizza is delicious.

T
Tanner A.

Piping hot in just 15 minutes while I did my grocery run next door! Friendly service, toppings are excellent and crust is better than average.

R
Roger M.

Terrific local pizza place we discovered! Very generous toppings with good, high quality ingredients!

C
Christine C.

Awesome bang for your buck. Best $5 meal in Bayfield. Pizza was great.

W
Wheel N.

Excellent tasting pizza!! Extremely friendly service even while they were busy! Will definitely return for a giant slice of pizza!!

J
J